In the Pink

Monday, November 23, 2009

Facebook Hurts. But You Don’t Have To.

Lately I feel like I should preface every post with “No. Seriously. I’m not making this up. I’m not that good.” Take this headline (please).

Depressed Woman Loses Benefits After Facebook Post in Which She Looked Happy
Insurance company cuts benefits after woman posts fun pictures to Facebook page.

Wait a minute. INSURANCE COMPANIES ARE WATCHING US ON FACEBOOK? So all that money I’ve been getting for my bogus hip replacement will be taken away? I’m going to start carrying a crutch around with me. I must mention my health in half of my status updates, like “Eileen Smith… hopes that her insurance plan never finds out about her numerous preexisting conditions! LOL!” (In retrospect, I did think it was strange that Aetna gave it an “I like” thumbs up.)

Back to the depressed woman who clearly wasn’t depressed because she was making contact with the outside world instead of sitting in her house staring vacantly at her dog while it held its leash, begging to go out. It turns out that a Canadian woman named Nathalie Blanchard posted some photos of her vacation and a few nights out with friends on her Facebook page. According to the article, Blanchard “appears to be having a good time.” Which is unacceptable given that she’s been on sick leave from her job at IBM’s Quebec office for the past year after she was diagnosed with major depression. I mean, if she had killed herself, they probably would have believed her.

So when the benefits were cut off and the checks stopped coming, Blanchard was told it was because “her Facebook pictures indicated she was no longer depressed and ready to return to work.” Oh BAM. This is like when Mike Brady proved that the guy wearing the neck brace in court was faking it after he turned his neck when Brady threw his briefcase on the floor. And it was like, don’t f*ck with the Bradys.

Blanchard insists that just because she has a few good hours once every couple of weeks doesn’t mean that she’s not still suffering from depression. It just means that she’s drunk for a few hours every couple of weeks. She and her lawyer Thomas Lavin are taking legal action against IBM and her health insurance company Manulife, arguing that her doctor was the one who recommended that she socialize with family and friends. Why not sue the doctor for malpractice? He should have told her to check into the nearest hospital and post photos of herself looking miserable in group therapy.

Lavin says that he’s aware of insurers that troll social networks in order to “red flag” someone and prompt further medical reviews or examinations. “It’s kind of a heads up to people about what they put on their Facebook accounts,” he said. “It’s going to be much more prevalent. I think employers and insurance companies need to have a protocol in a case like this.” I always knew this whole “social networking” thing would become a force of evil.

[via ABC]

Tagged: facebook, manulife, nathalie blanchard.

15 Responses to “Facebook Hurts. But You Don’t Have To.”


  1. lush says:

    “It just means that she’s drunk for a few hours every couple of weeks.”

    I apparently self-medicate for depression daily.

    Reply »


  2. The Freedom Doctor says:

    Nice Brady Bunch reference, that was a great episode.

    Reply »

    potted meat Reply:

    Re: Brady Bunch

    Often quoted are the classics here on ITP, FD. Nice to see you are versed in culture.

    /very civil posting; glad to see you are getting into the spirits….er, spirit.

    Reply »

    Orphan Babies R Yummy Reply:

    I agree. Thanks for referencing one of my all-time-favorite Brady Bunch episodes. (That and the one where Bobby and Cindy get lost at the Grand Canyon. “Bobby, Cindy, where are you?!”)

    Reply »


  3. treehugger says:

    Insurance Company’s cure for depression = just be happy. Now, back to work with you.

    Reply »


  4. potted meat says:

    Faced. Caught.

    unreal…..

    Reply »


  5. West Texas Hillbilly says:

    If this works both ways, I’m posting sad pictures of me and then suing IBM and Manurelife for a year’s pay.

    /That’ll be $823.19 please.

    Reply »

    potted meat Reply:

    Manurelife?!?!? No shit!

    /IT. COULD. WORK.

    Reply »


  6. Lake Worth Monster says:

    Decisions on when to terminate your care are way too important to leave up to the government (or your doctor). Thank God the insurance industry is taking up the slack on denying benefits for as many insured as possible and keeping it all in the public sector.

    Reply »

    Lake Worth Monster Reply:

    Oops. I meant the private sector. Perhaps it is time for my medication.

    Reply »


  7. Don't Mess w/ Pink says:

    Wait. I thought you controlled who could see your photos on facebook. Her insurance company was a facebook friend? I mean, I like my rep and all, but that’s taking it a little far.

    Reply »


  8. ellie says:

    Maybe she was too depressed to know how to use fb settings to lock down access to her page. Otherwise, it’s pretty much out there for the world to see.

    Reply »


  9. Rog says:

    You haven’t heard of layoff panels, a minor subset of the death panels? They also have hunger panels, sleep panels, and “making love” panels. It’s all in the fine print in the health insurance legislation.

    Reply »


  10. potted meat says:

    You can get all the various styles at Health Care Depot.

    Reply »


  11. Credentials says:

    You have to set your Facebook to private, or opt in to the public, or something.
    Or maybe she’s a Friend Whore and just randomly accepts friend requests without caring who they are.

    /Over 1,100, right here, and ALL of them were at my birthday party …

    Reply »

Leave a Reply

E-mail

Password

Remember me

Forgot your password?

X (close)

Registering gets you access to online content, allows you to comment on stories, add your own reviews of restaurants and events, and join in the discussions in our community areas such as the Recipe Swap.

In addition, current TEXAS MONTHLY magazine subscribers will get access to the feature stories from the two most recent issues. If you are a current subscriber, please enter your name and address exactly as it appears on your mailing label (except zip, 5 digits only). Not a subscriber? Subscribe online now.

E-mail

Re-enter your E-mail address

Choose a password

Re-enter your password

Name

 
 

Address

Address 2

City

State

Zip (5 digits only)

Country

What year were you born?

Are you...

Male Female

Remember me

X (close)