Some people might think of this venerable establishment as a “joint,” but we prefer to call it a swell place to spend an evening with friends. Hands down, our favorite order is a thin-crusted pizza dotted with sausage and cheese. But we’ve known folks to lick clean a purist’s platter of spaghetti with red sauce, smothered with Parmesan and black pepper. A slice of Key lime pie was, surprisingly, off kilter, with a soupy texture and too much whipped cream. (8/13)