Change of Pace

Matching the hypnotic flow of her best work, Lucinda Williams’ extraordinary releases have come in an unhurried fashion. Car Wheels on a Gravel Road survived a tortuous, six-year birth to become 1998’s most acclaimed recording, and 1992’s Sweet Old World was similarly fussed over. Essence is only the sixth release of a two-decade-plus career, but wrapping it in less than a year is likely an effort to put her doubting demons behind her. Yet by setting a pattern of overanalyzing every decision, she has also placed the bar impossibly high. As a result Essence seems lacking at first. The curious pacing starts at a crawl and throttles down from there; you’re five songs in before the rhythm section breaks much of a sweat. “Blue” moves so slowly that it tests your patience and seems nothing short of a love song to depression. “I Envy the Wind” and the childhood ode “Bus to Baton Rogue” both feel forced and unconvincing. And though a longtime Austin resident, her current Nashville tenure is starting to show, particularly in the grimace-guitar-squeals of Bo Ramsey. So what’s there to like? Everything else. Williams has let a relaxed edge emerge in her voice. Her words, even her very timbre, evoke longing in a way no one else can. “Broken Butterflies” and the smart kiss-off “Are You Down” (“Rain turns the dirt into mud/warm and messy/like your love”) direct a sharper edge at their victims, while “Lonely Girls” and “Out of Touch” find the perfect tone of tenderness. And the slow-boiling sexuality of the title track remains her strong suit. Few artists manage to work on such a consistently high plane. But with her newfound schedule, does twice as much Lucinda mean we risk losing the rare masterpiece? You do the math.

More Texas Monthly

Loading, please wait...

Most Read

  • Viewed
  • Past:
  • 1 week